“Very worrying” is how the government describes the results of the first ‘Monitor of mental health and substance use among higher education students’ (in Dutch), which has been compiled by the Trimbos Institute, the RIVM and the GGD.
This spring, 28,000 students from seven universities of applied sciences and eight research universities were questioned about their health and substance use. The survey was carried out at the time of the curfew and the closure of hospitality venues during the third wave of the coronavirus pandemic.
Weary of living
Two out of three students felt emotionally exhausted at that time. A quarter were weary of living and sometimes wished they could go to sleep and not wake up again. Four percent even had that wish frequently.
More than one in four students drinks excessively or heavily. Excessive (11 percent) means more than 21 glasses of alcohol per week for men and more than 14 for women. ‘Heavy’ drinkers (16 percent) consume six glasses (men) or four glasses (women) at least once a week.
- TU Delft students used more cannabis and experimented more with designer drugs during the corona crisis. Read more.
Cannabis appears to be pretty well accepted among students. One in three have smoked cannabis in the past twelve months and eight percent do so every week. The researchers looked at other types of substance use and addictions, gaming in particular: five percent spend too much time at their gaming consoles.
The TU Delft student council responded jointly that it is ‘very shocked’ by the report’s conclusions. “Unfortunately, we on the student council have been hearing these signals for some time,” confirmed student council chair Maarten de Nooijer.
There were concerns about students' mental health even before the coronavirus pandemic broke out, especially because of heavy study loads and rising levels of debt among students. This survey was announced at that time. This is the first time that students’ mental health has been investigated on this scale.
It emerges that those with high levels of debt from their studies use more substances. The researchers say that this is very worrying, even though they are unable to relate cause and effect.
Sixty-two percent of students experienced stress in the four weeks prior to filling in the questionnaire. Among more than half, this was caused by the coronavirus crisis, but an even larger number (72 percent) blame the stress on their studies.
- Delta surveys: On average, non-EER students have been drinking almost three more glasses alcohol per week since the first lockdown. Read more.
The researchers recommend an approach that involves substance abuse prevention among students, with a specific focus on groups such as international students and students with an impairment, who appear to be extra vulnerable. Educational institutions ought to pay more attention to students’ mental well-being as well.
De Nooijer emphasised that “International students are far from home and often feel isolated as a result. These problems have been going on for some time, but the pandemic year has amplified them.”
“It is of course likely that the complaints are related to the coronavirus pandemic and the associated measures”, Education Minister Ingrid van Engelshoven and State Secretary for Health Paul Blokhuis write in a letter to the House of Representatives.
However, according to these two government members, the report raises questions about how the education system is organised and financed. “The financial situation of students and their prospects on the labour and housing market can also play a role”, they argue.
‘The student loan system forces students to finish their programme as quickly as possible’
The government is going to hold talks with the institutions about a suitable approach. The survey will be repeated in two years to see how things are going with students.
Student council chair De Nooijer referred to the PwC report that was published at the stat of this year. The research bureau concluded that the universities have a budget gap of €1.1 billion. “And yet cuts are being made again this year. Universities continue to grow, but the budget is always being adjusted downwards.”
From a financial point of view, there is less enthusiasm among the students for extracurricular activities like taking part in advisory positions or having a say on the board of a programme, student or sport association. “The student loan system forces students to finish their programme as quickly as possible to limit the cost as much as possible. This results in students tending not to explore the world outside of studying.” The current educational system also falls short in that respect, he stressed. “Not passing one course means in some cases that a student has to put off starting a master’s programme by a year, which has the associated financial consequences. Giving students the chance to finish these courses during their master might just save them €12,000.”
The viewpoint of the student organisations, which have been sounding the alarm for years, has now been confirmed as correct. “It’s alarming to see that so many students are having difficulty making ends meet”, says Lisanne de Roos, chair of the Dutch National Students' Association. “After today, nobody can ever say that mental problems affect only a small number of students.”
‘Systemic causes such as the pressure to perform, loneliness and the loan system must be tackled’
The Dutch Student Union is shocked too. “Your student years should be about personal development but the opposite is the case: students are succumbing to the pressure to perform. That is extremely worrying”, says chair Ama Boahene.
She stresses that more needs to be done for the mental health of students. “Solutions that are currently being put forward are generally no more than palliative, whereas preventive policy is needed. Systemic causes such as the pressure to perform, loneliness and the loan system must be tackled. That is a responsibility that is shared by educational institutions and national politics.”
Extra student psychologists
The Association of Universities in the Netherlands, VSNU, recognises the “worrying picture” emerging from surveys of students’ mental health carried out by universities themselves. “The coronavirus period is hitting many students very hard. That’s why in recent times we have also been emphasising the importance of face-to-face teaching.”
Recently, the universities have appointed additional student psychologists and aim to improve their information provision. TU Delft also employed an additional psychologist last year – after urging by the Works Council and the student council. De Nooijer added, “We shall continue talking to the Executive Council to see what we action we can take to promote student welfare.”
HOP, Bas Belleman / Delta, Marjolein van der Veldt